I have been
a fan of Doctor Who for a long time. I have watched every episode known
to still exist, and have watched reconstructions of those no longer available…including
the BBC animations. Small tributes to Doctor Who show up in my game
writing. Some are obvious. Others are buried under layers of personal and
literary reference. I have watched all of Torchwood, all of Class,
all of The Sarah Jane Adventures, K-9 and Company, and even the K-9
spin-off TV series. I have read a large number of Doctor Who novels, and have
listened to many Big Finish audio
adventures, although I am nowhere near as much of a completist in that regard.
All of the
above is to indicate my default positon: I love the program, for all its warts
and protuberances. That’s where I’m coming from.
Also,
obviously, Spoilers Sweetie.
The Female Doctor
First off, let’s
deal with the gender change.
I’m going to
hope that this isn’t an issue for the Gentle Reader, but if it is, it should be
noted that the possibility was first brought up during Tom Baker’s run as the
Doctor. In The Hand of Fear, Eldrad uses Sarah Jane Smith to pattern his
body, and then regenerates into his more typical male form. When the Doctor
expresses surprise, Eldrad tells him that, as a Time Lord, the Doctor should have
known that this is possible.
The first
named Time Lord that we know switches gender is the Corsair, who is mentioned
in The
Doctor’s Wife. The Corsair seems unusual in that they changed gender
regularly. While this might be going on in the background more that it appears
to be, the few Time Lords whose regenerations we have followed do not seem to
follow this pattern: Romana, Borusa, Rassilon, Morbius, and River Song have not changed
gender within the program. The Master and the Doctor did so once, and the reaction
of the John Simm version of the Master seems to imply that it was not a welcome
change. Similarly, in Hell Bent, the General clearly finds
the change in gender an annoyance, albeit a minor one.
Gender
changes in Time Lords are therefore not common, but also not unheard of.
Moreover, the variance of change may be unlikely (the Doctor did not change
gender during his first cycle of regenerations, and it is implied that the
Master did not either) to highly likely (the Corsair).
The Doctor
changing gender is therefore very much supported by the program’s continuity,
and may well be a subconscious reaction on the part of the Doctor to the events
in Twice
Upon a Time. That seems to be the implication to me.
The Doctor Herself
I think that
Jodie Whittaker has a lot of potential as the Doctor, but I don’t think that
she has hit her full stride yet. That’s okay – it isn’t unusual for a new
Doctor to need a few stories before they discover themselves.
I like that
she has quiet moments – watching Ryan trying to learn to ride a bike in The
Woman Who Fell to Earth, and being in the background at Grace’s funeral
in the same story, are welcome. Life is not all frantic running about. Some of
the best bits in the original series were actually fairly quiet.
I like that
they have kept the Doctor’s selfishness and ego, and I wouldn’t mind seeing
more of it as the character progresses. Unlike previous Doctors, the 13th
seems to face some opposition to taking charge that she can’t just shout down. That
isn’t necessarily a problem – there really are gender biases that the Doctor
should be encountering – but she should be at least as capable as River Song or
Romana in this regard. Or Yaz for that matter.
We see a little of that in The Woman Who Fell to Earth, and in The
Ghost Monument, but the writing seems to be going more for “nurturing”
than “strong”, and that is also a gender bias.
There are
lots of nods to previous Doctors, going right back to the beginning of the
classic series – four companions, humans kidnapped (albeit accidentally in this
case), and the Hartnell-like appearance of the Capaldi outfit on Whittaker in The
Woman Who Fell to Earth. Its rough appearance, having fallen from
orbit, seems like a nod to Troughton to me. We’ve seen Venusian Akido from the
Pertwee era, and the outfit seems rather Colin Baker-esque. The relationship to
the companions seems to draw from Davison’s 5th Doctor, but without
the exasperation and friction.
Jodie
Whittaker is not a virtuoso of looking like she is running from explosions
or laser fire. This looks a bit unbelievable in The Ghost Monument, for
instance, where the robots would have to be worse shots than Imperial
Stormtroopers to have missed her. It was also not convincing in The
Tsuranga Conundrum. I can live with that, but I also think that the
writers should take it into account. The Gentle Reader may feel differently, of
course.
So far, the
Doctor seems to be stepping back, perhaps to find herself, except when she
needs to deliver a lesson or give a team inspirational meeting. That is not the
fault of the actor. I hope that this will change as the series continues. More
on this below.
Otherwise, I
am very happy with the 13th Doctor. Jodie Whittaker is an
accomplished actor, and, given opportunity, shines in the role.
The Companions
Graham, Yaz, and Ryan are all good. Let’s look at them individually, and then together as a group.
Graham: I wasn’t sure that I would like
Graham, given the way the actor was presented at the San Diego Comic Con panel,
but I find that he is fantastic to have on the TARDIS. He is an older man, with
a sense of humor, who is open to new experiences. He misses his wife, Grace,
and this is very well played out in particular in Arachnids in the UK.
Yaz: Rookie police officer who
knows that she could do more. And she could. Her family drives her crazy, but
is well-intentioned and likeable. The idea that she wants to do more, but is
being held back, would have been stronger had she not been a rookie. The implication
is that she should have been allowed to just jump the “gaining experience on
the job” part of being a police officer, and that sorting domestic disputes isn’t
actually valuable. The dispute we first see her resolving is a real dispute,
and people with the ability to resolve conflicts of this nature are important.
Ryan: Quiet young man, largely defined
so far by his unwillingness to call Graham “Grandfather”, his own father’s
unreliability, and his dyspraxia. Although this makes Ryan the first Doctor
Who companion with a known disability, it isn’t a known disability, and
while it has made some things difficult for him, it hasn’t really prevented him
from doing anything other than riding a bike. In many ways, it is treated like
Sarah Jane Smith’s fear of heights or enclosed spaces – something for someone
else to encourage him through successfully every time.
Together: The group functions well
together, and there are great moments of support and humor among them, but
there is very little tension between them, or between them and the Doctor. And
there are actually some obvious ways to bring this tension about:
Graham
demands that the Doctor use the TARDIS to go back and save Grace. If Krasko
could make minor alterations to try to prevent the Civil Rights Movement in Rosa,
why can’t the Doctor do something similar, but for good? We viewers may know that it won’t work, but Graham shouldn’t be so
accepting until he learns it the hard way.
When Yaz
goes back, eventually, she is still just a rookie cop. If she doesn’t go back,
she misses her family. She gave them up a little too easily at the ending of Arachnids
in the UK; that should come back to haunt her. Her wanting to do more,
but sometimes having to do the menial
things, should also be a point of tension, because sometimes the small things are what we have to do.
I could see the Doctor getting quite angry about this when Yaz tells her that
she came aboard the TARDIS to do more. The growth arc for Yaz should include
realizing how important her job was, even if she never returns to it.
Ryan is on a
67th Century medical ship, and not once does he ask whether or not
they can cure his dyspraxia? Another obvious source of tension: Ryan blames
himself after his dyspraxia prevents him from succeeding in something more important than riding a bike!
What if someone dies as a result? What is someone is critically injured and might die? And when are we going to
learn why he refuses to bond with Graham?
Those great
moments of support between the characters would be more powerful if we first
saw those characters divided by their own conflicts. The Tardis crew under
Peter Davison or William Hartnell offer plenty of examples to draw from.
The Adversaries
The Woman
Who Fell to Earth: Tzim-Sha
of the Stenza has an imposing first appearance, and a certain “ick” factor, but
the Stenza themselves are not nearly as menacing as, say, the original
Sontarans, the Cybermen, or the Daleks. They would need
a lot of development to
be a serious threat to the Doctor.
The DNA
bombs, on the other hand, and the data-gathering coils, were excellent.
One benefit
of Tzim-Sha was that it allowed the full sarcasm of the Doctor to shine through
when she kept referring to him as “Tim Shaw”. OTOH, when she moralized about Karl
kicking him off the crane? (1) There was nothing stopping Tzim-Shaw from
grabbing Karl and teleporting away otherwise. (2) If Tzim-Shaw could teleport
away (as he did), then Karl wasn’t actually necessarily harming him in any way.
That the
Stenza keep their victim-trophies in stasis between life and death, and that
this is the condition of a specific human girl in the plot of the episode,
doesn’t even seem to register with the Doctor. I hope that we see some
resolution to this in the future.
The Ghost
Monument: We learn a little more about the Stenza in passing,
suggesting that they may be the main baddies of this season.
The planet Desolation
is said to have been made “cruel”, and the weapons developers on that world
have tried to make it inimical to life. They really haven’t succeeded very
well. In terms of a deadly environment, Desolation is put to shame by places
the Doctor has encountered going back to Skaro…or even primitive Earth in An
Unearthly Child. At least on Desolation, the problems nicely compartmentalize
themselves, and are pretty easily defeated. Facing Remnants? Here is a handy
pocket of gas to defeat them with!
Ilin is the
guy who set up this version of The Amazing (Intergalactic) Race.
Well acted, but compromises too quickly when the Doctor suggests a solution
from The
Hunger Games. The story would have been made far stronger had he
refused to compromise. Nonetheless, he is a “villain” who is worthy of
reprising his role.
The
Desolation robots have the worst aim and tracking skills of any science fiction
robots I have ever seen. Because they recover quickly from the Doctor’s EMP,
her solution is only marginally better than Ryan’s.
The Remnants
were a great idea, but I wish that they had been used to do more than provide
exposition. This episode could really have used some “red shirts” to
demonstrate how dangerous the threats really are. They seem to be
location-specific, so unless Team TARDIS returns to Desolation, we are unlikely
to see them again. The set-up for this monster, where it is seen on-screen
several times before it is revealed to be an adversary, was effective.
Rosa: The
main villain, Krasko, is pretty two-dimensional, and racist bus driver James
Blake is like a character from the Mirror Universe version of The
Andy Griffith Show. For actual menace, police officer Mason steals the
show.
Arachnids
in the UK: If the data coil from The Woman Who Fell to Earth
is the best visual in the new series (and I think it is), the CGI spiders here
come a close and creepy second. Sadly, there is no mention of Metebelis III (“I’ve
met bigger”) and how the Doctor intended to kill them humanely isn’t
explicated.
The queen
spider dying at the end is a wasted opportunity. Imagine if the Doctor wanted
to trap the spiders in the Panic Room so that she could materialize the TARDIS
around them (in a holding cell of some sort) to transport to a world where they
could survive. (Note: Not Metebelis III!) Then, when the
queen is dying due to respiratory failure, she can realize that she cannot get the TARDIS there in time to save
her. Robertson’s solution of shooting the spider becomes, in fact, the most
humane thing she can do.
Robertson himself
is smarter cartoon Trump.
The
Tsuranga Conundrum: The P'Ting was kind of silly to look at,
and, although people died as a result of its actions, it was cute enough that
kids were happy it survived at the end, its tummy glowing from the energy of a
bomb it absorbed. Because of that bomb, The
Tsuranga itself was a kind of an adversary, and one with far more dramatic
potential than we got to see on-screen.
Direction, Filming, and Sound
Visually,
the new series is a real treat. Compared to the effects of, say, the Colin
Baker years, we have come a long, long way in telling stories visually.
The sound is
mostly good. Sylvester McCoy’s Doctor got to deal with the worst sound problems
in the program’s long run, but there are bits of dialogue and exposition in The
Tsuranga Conundrum that I found hard to make out.
The Writing
Here is
where the new series really falls down, as far as I am concerned. Most of the
stories fail to have the rising tension required to keep them from falling
flat. The inter-companion dialogue is great, for what it is, but also lacks
interpersonal tension.
The Woman
Who Fell to Earth: As a regeneration story, this was pretty solid.
The Doctor and companions had plenty to do. There was some actual light
conflict between them. There were some excellent quiet moments. The Doctor uses
what is at hand to solve the problems she faces – this was very, very welcome.
Looking back at the series so far, this may be the best episode.
The Ghost
Monument: The Doctor and companions have to seek out the TARDIS
on a planet making lackluster attempts to kill them. They are in the company of
fierce competitors who are actually only making lackluster attempts at
competing with each other. One has a legendary ability to nap that is only used
to introduce a monster.
This is
easily the worst writing in the series to date. Sadly, it would have been very
easy to fix:
- First off, make it two episodes, because you should be fitting a lot in here.
- Companions
have just been kidnapped from Earth. There should be some conflict/tension as a
result.
- Competitors
are either going to get rich or die. There should be some real tension as a
result. We should never be allowed to forget how this ends.
- Cigar-guy
has more than one cigar. Almost kills them all in an acetylene field. This
makes the resolution to the Remnants more believable.
- Someone
almost dips into the water before the Doctor realizes it would kill them.
- Robots start
as slow/poor shots, but get better over time. Never give up pursuit. The area
requires more debris, things to hide behind, turns, etc., to make the
characters’ survival believable.
- Ilin refuses
to accept that both contestants win. One must believe that the other will share
the prize. This gives cigar guy an opportunity to grow. When Ilin disappears
with the winner, leaving cigar guy and Team TARDIS, the Remnants and robots are
closing in. The TARDIS appears the run, and only then does the Doctor remember
that she has no key. After a panicked moment, she clicks her fingers and the
TARDIS door opens.
- The Doctor
uses the TARDIS to trace back the teleporter, confronting Ilin and demanding
that the other contestant keep her word. She does….if cigar guy will help her
rescue her family from the Stenza-ruined world they are on.
- The Doctor
admits to Graham that she got the sunglasses from the charity shop where she
got her clothes. “My pockets were empty when I fell into your life, remember?
Where else could they have come from?”
Rosa: Mostly
positive. I am glad that the Doctor didn’t turn out to be the cause of history.
Although it may seem like a wasted opportunity that the Doctor wasn’t the white
woman Rosa Parks was supposed to give up her seat to, I am glad that wasn’t the
case. The villain was one-dimensional, and the least effective part of the
story. Ryan making coffee is a good parallel to early Doctor Who stories where
Polly did the same.
This would
have been a better story if it had been done as a true historical. The TARDIS
breaks down, and the Doctor must seek repairs. Team TARDIS’s actions set up the
potential break with history. The Doctor is devastated when she realizes that
they have to set history back on track by increasing local suffering. Is there
another way?
Arachnids
in the UK: Mostly positive, although why the hell Yaz isn’t
worried about her family in the apartment complex is beyond me. She gives up
her established life at the end far too easily. That needs to come back to bite
her. The companions accepting that they would have to interact with these
creepy, creepy, and altogether creepy things was far too easily come by.
I’ve already mentioned, earlier, how the answer was too pat. Were all of the
spiders in the hotel when the panic room was filled? Or were some of them
ranging afield? How was the Doctor going to deal with them humanely? There was
some indication (sealing them into the hotel, for instance) that the spiders
had a form of intelligence. Exploring that would have been cool.
The
Tsuranga Conundrum: Mostly positive. I liked Yoss. Again, the
Doctor uses what is at hand (yes!) to solve the problem, but it is surprising
that magnetic containment fields as a means of holding the P’ting didn’t even
come up. The story would have been helped had the Tsuranga had more patients, even if we didn’t get to know them, or
even if they were just implied – see Smith and Jones, The
Empty Child, New Earth, or The Invisible Enemy for
examples.
Also, if you
can stun the P’Ting, wrap it up, and then punt it down the corridor, can’t you
simply repeat these actions all the way to the airlock?
Conclusions
Very much
looking forward to more Jodie Whittaker.
Very much
liking the companions filling out the TARDIS crew.
Love the nods
to earlier Doctors.
The visuals
have been awesome; make sure that the sound is clear.
Hoping for
improvements in the writing, especially tensions in Team TARDIS itself.
Remember that resolving these tensions is the heart of the best episodes in
Doctor Who, and that they have existed in the program since An Unearthly Child.
Glad to see
new worlds, new adversaries, and things that the Doctor doesn’t know. The
universe is a big place!